EVICTION GURU

CALL 510-343-JOEL

Berkeley’s Eviction Protections

Berkeley, California, is known for its strong tenant protections and comprehensive rent control measures. Landlords operating in this city must navigate a complex legal landscape, particularly when it comes to evictions. Understanding Berkeley’s specific eviction protections is crucial for landlords to ensure compliance with local regulations and avoid costly legal disputes. This article provides a detailed overview of Berkeley’s eviction protections, focusing on the key aspects that landlords need to be aware of.

Overview of Berkeley’s Eviction Protections

Berkeley’s eviction protections are primarily governed by the Berkeley Rent Stabilization and Eviction for Good Cause Ordinance (Berkeley Rent Ordinance), codified in the Berkeley Municipal Code (BMC) Chapter 13.76. This ordinance provides robust protections for tenants, making it significantly more challenging for landlords to evict tenants compared to other cities in California. The ordinance is designed to prevent arbitrary evictions and ensure that tenants can remain in their homes unless there is a legitimate, legally recognized reason for eviction.

Key Provisions of the Berkeley Rent Ordinance

The Berkeley Rent Ordinance limits the grounds on which a landlord can evict a tenant. These grounds are often referred to as “just causes” for eviction. Below are the primary just causes allowed under the ordinance:

  1. Nonpayment of Rent: A tenant can be evicted for failing to pay rent. However, the landlord must follow specific procedures, including providing a proper notice to pay rent or quit.
  2. Breach of Lease: If a tenant violates a material term of the lease agreement and fails to cure the breach after receiving notice, they may be subject to eviction.
  3. Nuisance: Tenants who create a nuisance, such as causing significant disturbances or damaging the property, can be evicted.
  4. Illegal Activity: Engaging in illegal activities on the premises can be grounds for eviction.
  5. Owner Move-In (OMI): Landlords or their immediate family members can evict tenants if they intend to move into the unit. However, there are stringent requirements, including providing the tenant with relocation assistance.
  6. Ellis Act Evictions: Landlords can withdraw units from the rental market under the Ellis Act, but they must comply with extensive procedural requirements and provide substantial relocation payments to displaced tenants.
  7. Substantial Rehabilitation: If a unit requires substantial rehabilitation that cannot be completed with the tenant in place, the landlord may evict the tenant. However, this is closely regulated, and the landlord must demonstrate that the work is necessary and substantial.
  8. Withdrawal of Unit from Rental Market: Similar to the Ellis Act, this allows landlords to remove rental units from the market, but it is subject to stringent requirements.

The Importance of Just Cause for Eviction

Under the Berkeley Rent Ordinance, a landlord cannot evict a tenant without a just cause. The ordinance defines just cause in narrow terms, limiting the ability of landlords to remove tenants arbitrarily. Even if a landlord has a just cause, they must provide the tenant with proper notice, and in some cases, offer relocation assistance.

Notice Requirements

The type of notice a landlord must provide depends on the grounds for eviction. For example:

  • Nonpayment of Rent: Requires a 3-day notice to pay rent or quit.
  • Breach of Lease: Requires a 3-day notice to cure or quit.
  • Owner Move-In: Requires a 30- or 60-day notice, depending on the length of the tenancy, along with a relocation assistance payment.

Failure to provide the correct notice can invalidate the eviction and expose the landlord to legal penalties.

Rent Control and Its Impact on Evictions

Berkeley’s strong rent control laws further complicate the eviction process. The Berkeley Rent Stabilization Board (BRSB) oversees rent control in the city and has established specific rules and procedures that landlords must follow.

Rent Control Basics

Berkeley’s rent control applies to most residential rental units built before June 30, 1980. It limits the amount by which landlords can increase rent and provides tenants with certain protections against evictions. If a landlord attempts to evict a tenant to circumvent rent control regulations, such as by falsely claiming an owner move-in or substantial rehabilitation, they can face significant legal consequences.

Owner Move-In (OMI) Evictions: A Closer Look

Owner Move-In evictions are one of the more common just causes landlords use to regain possession of their rental properties in Berkeley. However, OMI evictions are highly regulated to prevent abuse.

Requirements for OMI Evictions

  • Intent to Occupy: The landlord or a qualifying family member must intend to occupy the unit as their primary residence for at least 36 consecutive months.
  • Relocation Assistance: Landlords are required to provide tenants with substantial relocation assistance, which can be thousands of dollars, depending on the tenant’s income and the length of the tenancy.
  • Restrictions on Re-Renting: If the landlord or family member fails to occupy the unit as required, or if the unit is re-rented within a certain period, the landlord may face penalties and be required to pay additional compensation to the tenant.

Challenges and Risks

OMI evictions can be legally challenging, as tenants may contest the eviction on the grounds that the landlord lacks a genuine intent to occupy the unit. If the court finds that the eviction was conducted in bad faith, the landlord may be liable for damages, including punitive damages.

Ellis Act Evictions: Complex and Costly

The Ellis Act allows landlords to withdraw rental units from the market, effectively evicting all tenants in the process. However, Ellis Act evictions in Berkeley are subject to some of the most stringent regulations in the state.

Ellis Act Procedures

  • Notice Requirements: Landlords must provide a 120-day notice to tenants, or a one-year notice for seniors or disabled tenants.
  • Relocation Assistance: Landlords must pay significant relocation assistance, which is calculated based on the tenant’s age, disability status, and length of tenancy.
  • Re-Renting Restrictions: If the landlord returns the unit to the rental market within a certain period (generally five years), they must offer the unit back to the displaced tenant at the same rent-controlled rate.

Legal Risks

Ellis Act evictions are often contested, leading to protracted legal battles. Landlords must be prepared to demonstrate that they are genuinely withdrawing the unit from the rental market and not using the Ellis Act as a pretext to circumvent rent control laws.

Substantial Rehabilitation: A Narrow Path

Substantial rehabilitation evictions allow landlords to remove tenants if the property requires significant repairs that cannot be completed while the tenant remains in the unit. However, Berkeley’s regulations require landlords to meet a high threshold to justify such evictions.

Requirements

  • Scope of Work: The rehabilitation must be so extensive that it requires the tenant to vacate the premises.
  • Proof of Necessity: Landlords must provide detailed plans and evidence that the work is necessary and cannot be performed with the tenant in place.
  • Relocation Assistance: Tenants are entitled to relocation assistance, similar to that required for OMI and Ellis Act evictions.

Conclusion

Berkeley’s eviction protections are among the most comprehensive and tenant-friendly in California. Landlords must be diligent in understanding and complying with these regulations to avoid legal pitfalls. Whether dealing with just cause requirements, navigating rent control laws, or managing the complexities of OMI, Ellis Act, or substantial rehabilitation evictions, landlords in Berkeley must approach each situation with caution and thorough preparation.

Citations

  1. Berkeley Municipal Code, Chapter 13.76 (Berkeley Rent Stabilization and Eviction for Good Cause Ordinance).
  2. California Civil Code § 1946.1 (Termination of tenancy).
  3. California Code of Civil Procedure § 1161 (Grounds for unlawful detainer).
  4. California Code of Civil Procedure § 1179 (Relief from forfeiture).
  5. California Ellis Act (California Government Code § 7060-7060.7).
  6. Berkeley Rent Stabilization Board Regulations (OMI Evictions, Ellis Act Evictions, Substantial Rehabilitation).
  7. California Code of Civil Procedure § 664.6 (Stipulated judgments).